Forum › Forums › Tractor Operation And Maintenance › Jinma 284 engine knock
- This topic has 23 replies, 6 voices, and was last updated 9 years, 3 months ago by Bob Rooks.
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
July 17, 2015 at 11:35 am #31061
New CTOA member. I have a 2012 Jinma 284 with 35 hours. It starts easily and seems to run fine. Problem: The engine emits a knocking sound with bluish smoke from the exhaust through all operating ranges. The manufacturer manuals point to either a faulty injector or injector pump timing. In my initial troubleshooting, I used an infra red thermometer to measUre Each cylinder temp at the exhaust manifold. The #1 cylinder read 30 degrees cooler than the other two. I removed the #1 injector, Removed the nozzle, soaked all parts in acetone, and used compressed air to clear out any debris. After reinstalling the injector the engine ran the same. Next, I swapped out the #1 injector with #2. The engine ran the same and the #1 cylinder still ran 30 degrees cooler. At this point I don’t know what I should try next. Could it be valve lash or injector timing? Any troublshooting help would be greatly appreciated.
-
July 17, 2015 at 2:57 pm #37954
I would look at valve lash, then a compression test. Injector timing isn't going to throw just one cylinder off. When I bought my 2008 it was a crate unit. Before firing it up for the first time I checked the valve lash, and one cylinder had one valve way too tight. Hopefully it's nothing worse.
-
July 17, 2015 at 5:51 pm #37955
Sounds like youve got air in your system. This is a common issue. To fix it, while the tractor is running crack the injector lines one at a time and let diesel fuel come out for a few seconds before re-sealing. You will hear the difference in the engine when you do this. Make sure you do this to ALL of them, not just #1. I can pretty much guarantee this will fix your problem. Also, as to why #1 is running a little cooler, is because your coolant enters the engine block in the front and as it heads towards the back it heats up from engine heat. Hopefully this helps! If you have any more questions feel free to give me a call.
Trevor Nystrom
Keno Tractors
Parts Department
541-850-8193
866-363-8193
Tyler Nystrom
Keno Tractors
parts@kenotractors.com
866-363-8193
Phone hours: M-F 8am to 5:30pm PST Sat 9am to 1pm PST -
July 17, 2015 at 6:15 pm #37957
That has no effect on exhaust gas temperature Trevor, it is a compression issue, but due to the presence of blue smoke I suspect broken piston rings.
A dribbling injector can cause knocking from over-fueling on one cylinder, but since that has been discounted by switching injectors, that is not the cause. Injector timing will not cause this.
Bear in mind that #1 cylinder is closest to the fan so that portion will run cooler on the surface. Try your thermo test again this time shielding the manifold from fan air.
You're doing good.
Account deleted.
-
July 17, 2015 at 11:10 pm #37961
Thanks all for the reSponses. Your diagnoses run the full gamut And each makes sense. Fortunately I can try each recommendation starting with the easiEst. Give me a couple of days and I’ll post my findings.
-
July 18, 2015 at 8:06 pm #37964
Update…..I started with loosening the fuel line to each injector and allowing each to bleed for about 10 seconds. There was a definite RPM drop as each line was loosened but the RPMs recovered as the lines were tightened. The engine knock did seem to improve and the blue smoke seemed to disappear but I’m not fully convinced the problem is remedied.
My next step is to retorque the head (Although the engine only has 37 hours) and to Check valve lash. The owners manual describes the Adjustment procedure but I find it difficult to see the crank pulley markings and the reference arrow on the block. Do I need to pull the radiator and/or the alTernator to gain access? If anyone knows of an easier way please advise.
FinAlly, I rechecked the cylinder temps but this time I shielded the surfaces from the fan air but found temps to read the same with the #1 cylinder running ~30 degrees cooler than Cylinders 2 & 3.
I welcome any advice/feedback.
-
July 19, 2015 at 4:37 pm #37967
first make sure that your fuel cut off(engine stop) is fully engaged pull the valve cover. On a warm engine retorque the head. Then turn engine over with the trans. in neutral and look at the valves when both valve rockers will rattle on one cylinder check the lash adjust as necessary go to next cylinder. Hopefully you will not have a cylinder that the valves are so tight that they will not rattle. But if you do you have found a problem. remember better a little loose than to tight.
-
July 19, 2015 at 4:45 pm #37968
sorry I did not address the pulling the rad. if you have a socket that will fit the crank pulley bolt with out hitting the rad. then no. most people like to change all fluids around 50 hr. so if you are close pulling the radiator and rinsing it out is not a bad idea these engines have some casting sand in them when new so washing it out will save the water pump .I think I changed coolant at 100 hours also and have not had any water pump issues 500 hrs. later
-
July 20, 2015 at 2:25 pm #37972
Thanks David. I waS unable to get a socket on the crank pulley bolt and decided against pulling the radiator. InstEad, I removed the glow plugs and then used a remote starter switch to turn the engine To position the valve rockers for adjustment. About half the valves required some adjusting but fortunately none of them were overly tight.
My problem now is reassembling the compression release mechanism in the valve cover. There is a small coupler part that installs between the handle meChanism on the valve cover and the pressure reduction shaft on the valve rocker assembly. It’s got me baffled. Since my tractor doesn’t use the pressure relief feature I’m wondering if I can simply remove those componeNTs and not worry about it.
Comments from anyone?
-
July 20, 2015 at 6:48 pm #37974
the compression release depending on how far north or south you live from the equator how useful it is I live in Tn. only 4 miles from Ga. the compression release does not do much for me except being able to top off the oil filter after a oil change without the engine compression load on the starter , there are tractors with shuttle shifts that this is left off.
-
July 23, 2015 at 9:42 am #37981
The blue smoke would concern me also that the misfire stayed with the hole and didn't follow the injector if it were mine I would drain a small amount of oil out the drain plug its a little messy but if you do it with the engine cold its not too bad pull the plug collect about a 1/2 a cup put the plug back in so you don't lose all the oil then check the oil for small chunks of metal or metallic flakes if there is metal present then something going on with the mechanical part of your engine broken rings or piston or when the engine/tractor was assembled some careless person left some debris on the intake side which got into the engine and caused some damage I hope not as this can be an expensive repair.
-
July 23, 2015 at 1:33 pm #37982
Yes, I agree. You can also get an oil analysis performed for about $25 and that will tell you a lot. Maybe more than you want to know.
Account deleted.
-
July 24, 2015 at 1:05 pm #37985
Thanks for the input. My initial assumption was that the problem was associated with the #1 cyl since the exhaust temp ran 30 degrees cooler than cylinders 2 and 3. However, that has been explained away by the proximity of the #1 cyl to the cooled water from the radiator. Sounded plausible to me.
In any case, I adjusted the valves and bled the injector fuel lines per KenOtractors’ recommendation. My 284 fIred right up running smooth and minus the engine knock and blue exhaust smoke. I note just a little bit of gray smoke. So at this point I’m a happy camper.
-
July 25, 2015 at 1:10 am #37987
The #1 cylinder being cooler because of the coolant pump is pure bunk. I've operated many diesels large and small with thermocouples, never had an issue like that. The temperature you were measuring was of the exhaust gasses after combustion. The only way those temps would be lower would be inadequate combustion, which could be caused by lower compression from incorrect valve lash. Whitish grey smoke is unburned fuel or coolant in the combustion chamber. Glad you're happy with the fix, but I suggest doing another quick shielded thermometer check to be sure.
Account deleted.
-
July 25, 2015 at 1:18 pm #37992
And let the engine run with the fan shielded for at least three minutes before taking your reading, allowing the manifold temps to equalize.
Account deleted.
-
July 25, 2015 at 3:29 pm #37994
Thanks Bob. I did not run another temp check after adjusting the valve lash. I’ll check it again per your recommendation and post my findings.
-
July 27, 2015 at 9:19 pm #37996
Just as a curiosity I'll run the thermo check on my TY395 dozer engine too. I'll perform the test at 1,500 r/m no load speed at operating temp. We can compare notes.
Account deleted.
-
August 7, 2015 at 3:33 am #38012
Just bumping this thread. I took a video of my EGT's through the manifold wall and shielded the fan draft. I took two series of checks, one on the top of the manifold, and one on the side. I just got back to civilization so will process the video soon.
Account deleted.
-
August 9, 2015 at 3:25 pm #38014
For your entertainment:
Account deleted.
-
August 9, 2015 at 3:35 pm #38015
I'm done. Let the wives' tales, misinformation, and superstitions run amok.
Account deleted.
-
August 10, 2015 at 10:56 am #38018
Ive had quite a bit of experience with diesels…. not just tractors. Ive got thermocoupler in my 12v cummins, and my temps in the back of the engine are always hotter then the front.. Ive talked to several people and done a bit of research. I believe its because of how the water circulates in the block. Don't believe its complete “bunk” LOL.
Tyler Nystrom
Keno Tractors
parts@kenotractors.com
866-363-8193
Phone hours: M-F 8am to 5:30pm PST Sat 9am to 1pm PST -
August 10, 2015 at 12:24 pm #38019
Modern internal combustion engines, gasoline or diesel, are designed for a maximum Δ-T of 15°F. To have more would create thermal shock and premature failure of cylinder walls. I didn't make this up. Long ago there was much discussion in SAE white papers. Check it out for yourself. Coolant circulation is designed SPECIFICALLY to eliminate hot or cold spots
Here is a Cummins K38 (V-12). How is #1 cylinder always going to run cooler? Or the cylinders at the rear allowed to run hotter? That's very poor thermal efficiency.
I maintain that your claim of lower combustion temperatures due to the proximity of the coolant pump is without merit. Please name your credible sources of information.
Account deleted.
-
August 11, 2015 at 11:00 am #38022
The type of engines we are talking about is a straight 3 or 4 or 6. Much different cooling circulation then a v12. Do a bit of research on straight style motors running hotter temps in the back few cylinders then the front few. Theres tons of people saying this is how their engines run. Yes, you most likely are right. But real life experience is sometimes more informative then what is “suppose to happen”. As you even saw on your Yuchai the front cyl were warmer then the back.. lol so you cant argue to much either way. I believe that is why they run hotter. And it does make sense, coolant in straight style engines runs from the front to the back. Getting hotter as it reaches the back of the engine. Sounds pretty logical to me.
Tyler Nystrom
Keno Tractors
parts@kenotractors.com
866-363-8193
Phone hours: M-F 8am to 5:30pm PST Sat 9am to 1pm PST -
August 11, 2015 at 12:31 pm #38028
Well then I will concede that I don't know anything about diesel engines, and will no longer provide misinformation as a contributor to this site. Since you cannot back up your claims with verifiable sources I still maintain your claims to be without merit. I have never encountered your claims on Caterpillar, Cummins, Allis Chalmers, Buda, and other inline diesel engines equipped with pyrometers.
Account deleted.
-
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.